What Happens if Your First Embryo Transfer Fails?
An ACRC Surrogacy webinar recap with Dr. Semara Thomas of Beverly Hills Fertility
If your first embryo transfer is unsuccessful, your fertility doctor will usually review the embryo, uterine lining, hormone preparation and pregnancy test results before recommending another attempt. One unsuccessful transfer does not, by itself, mean that future transfers will fail or that a gestational surrogate needs to be replaced.
After months of preparation, an unsuccessful embryo transfer can feel deeply disappointing. Intended parents may wonder whether their embryos are suitable, whether the treatment should change or how soon they can try again. A surrogate may also feel sadness, uncertainty or guilt.
In an ACRC Surrogacy educational webinar, Dr. Semara Thomas, a double board-certified reproductive endocrinology and infertility specialist at Beverly Hills Fertility, discussed how physicians evaluate an unsuccessful transfer and help everyone understand the next steps.
Her central message: an unsuccessful result calls for a thoughtful review, compassionate communication and an individualized plan.
Does one failed embryo transfer mean something is wrong?
No. One unsuccessful embryo transfer does not automatically identify a problem with the embryo, the surrogate or the treatment protocol. Embryo implantation is a complex biological process, and no transfer has a guaranteed outcome.
Dr. Thomas explained that physicians consider the circumstances of the individual cycle rather than assuming that one result predicts the entire journey. Relevant factors can include the age of the egg provider when the eggs were retrieved, embryo development, genetic testing results and the condition of the uterus.
For intended parents pursuing gestational surrogacy, this distinction matters: a disappointing first result is a reason to ask informed questions, not a reason to assign blame.
What do pregnancy test results mean after an embryo transfer?
An unsuccessful transfer and an early pregnancy loss are different outcomes. Understanding the difference helps explain why follow-up care and the timing of another transfer may vary.
Result | What it generally means | What happens next |
Negative pregnancy blood test | The test does not detect a pregnancy at the clinic's scheduled testing point. | The clinic reviews the cycle and provides instructions about medication and follow-up. |
Biochemical pregnancy | Pregnancy hormone, called hCG, is detected, but the pregnancy does not progress to ultrasound confirmation. | The clinic follows hormone levels and confirms that the pregnancy has resolved. |
Early miscarriage | A pregnancy ends after it has been identified clinically, often by ultrasound. | Follow-up depends on the findings, treatment needed and physical recovery. |
In the webinar, Dr. Thomas described blood pregnancy testing approximately 9–12 days after embryo transfer, depending on the clinic's protocol. A positive result may require repeat blood tests and later ultrasound assessment.
One hCG result does not establish the location or viability of a pregnancy. The treating clinic interprets the pattern of results and arranges further evaluation when needed. Follow its instructions rather than relying on symptoms or home pregnancy tests.
Why can a genetically tested embryo transfer fail?
An embryo reported as euploid after PGT-A can still fail to implant. PGT-A, or preimplantation genetic testing for aneuploidy, screens sampled embryo cells for chromosome number abnormalities. It does not assess every aspect of embryo health or guarantee implantation, pregnancy or live birth.
Dr. Thomas discussed several factors physicians may consider:
Embryo development: how the embryo developed before freezing and its appearance under the microscope.
Egg age at retrieval: the age of the person providing the eggs when those eggs were collected, rather than simply the intended parent's current age.
Uterine preparation: the lining's response to the prescribed treatment.
Hormone support: progesterone exposure and levels, interpreted within the specific protocol.
Uterine findings: whether a polyp, fibroid, scar tissue or another finding warrants evaluation.
Embryo grading and genetic testing provide different information. Neither can explain every unsuccessful result, and a doctor may not identify a single definite cause after one attempt.
What does the fertility doctor review before a second transfer?
The first step is generally a review of the completed cycle, rather than an automatic change to treatment.
Dr. Thomas described reviewing how the uterine lining responded, whether medication adjustments were needed, progesterone results and how the surrogate felt during preparation. The physician also considers whether the outcome was a negative test, a biochemical pregnancy or a miscarriage.
A follow-up appointment is an opportunity to ask:
Did the embryo and transfer cycle meet the clinic's expectations?
Was the lining's development appropriate for this protocol?
Were there medication side effects or administration concerns?
Is there a specific finding that would change the next treatment plan?
What needs to happen before another transfer can begin?
If preparation was appropriate, the doctor may recommend another transfer using a similar protocol. Keeping an appropriate plan can be a considered medical decision.
Do you need additional testing after one unsuccessful transfer?
Not necessarily. Additional testing should address a specific clinical question and have a reasonable chance of influencing care.
In the webinar, Dr. Thomas explained that she does not routinely recommend extensive additional testing after a single unsuccessful transfer when the cycle parameters were appropriate. Tests may involve extra appointments, medication, biopsies, discomfort and expense.
Repeated unsuccessful transfers or particular medical findings may lead to a different discussion. One unsuccessful transfer alone should not be treated as a diagnosis of recurrent implantation failure.
Before agreeing to an additional test, ask what it measures, what evidence supports its use and how each possible result would change treatment. ASRM's 2026 committee opinion also finds insufficient evidence to support routine endometrial receptivity array testing in patients with recurrent implantation failure.
How soon can you try another embryo transfer?
The timing depends on the previous outcome, medical clearance and the surrogate's readiness. There is no single waiting period that applies to every journey.
After a negative pregnancy test, Dr. Thomas explained that some patients may be able to prepare for another cycle without a prolonged delay, once their physician gives instructions and clearance.
After a biochemical pregnancy, miscarriage or ectopic pregnancy, additional follow-up may be necessary. The clinic may need to confirm that pregnancy hormone levels have resolved, assess the uterus or allow recovery from treatment. Ectopic pregnancy treatment can involve specific waiting requirements that must be discussed with the physician.
Practical and emotional readiness matter, too. Travel, monitoring appointments, time away from work and the surrogate's preferences should be included in planning. Do not stop, restart or change fertility medication without instructions from the treating clinic.
Should intended parents change surrogates after a failed transfer?
One unsuccessful embryo transfer alone is not a reason to assume that a different surrogate is needed.
Dr. Thomas emphasized that an unsuccessful result does not establish that the surrogate did anything wrong. Any discussion about continuing with a gestational carrier should consider medical findings, treatment history and the wishes of everyone involved.
For intended parents and surrogates who have built a relationship, a supportive review can help preserve trust. Questions should focus on what the team has learned and how to move forward together.
What additional costs should intended parents ask about?
The cost of another embryo transfer depends on the clinic's financial arrangements, the agency agreement and the individual journey.
Potential expenses to clarify include another transfer procedure, medication, bloodwork, ultrasound monitoring, additional testing, travel and applicable surrogate reimbursements.
Before the next attempt, ask whether multiple transfers are included in your clinic package, which services are billed separately and which expenses are addressed in your agency and surrogacy agreements. Request a written explanation of expected charges and exclusions.
Book a free consultation with ACRC Surrogacy to discuss agency support, coordination and questions to raise when planning your journey. Medical recommendations and clinic charges should be confirmed directly with the treating fertility clinic.
How does ACRC Surrogacy support intended parents after an unsuccessful transfer?
An unsuccessful transfer can affect everyone involved. Clear information and personal support help intended parents and surrogates navigate the uncertainty together.
During the webinar, ACRC described dedicated communication groups for matched intended parents and surrogates, with case manager and management involvement. The case manager helps coordinate communication between the intended parents, surrogate and clinic so questions and next steps can be addressed.
This support includes helping everyone stay informed about scheduling and practical arrangements while the fertility physician directs medical care. ACRC also discussed access to therapists it works with; intended parents and surrogates can ask their case manager about available support and arrangements.
No one should feel that a disappointing result reduces them to a medical outcome. Taking time to acknowledge feelings, ask questions and understand the next plan is part of a supported journey.
Frequently asked questions about a failed first embryo transfer
Can a second embryo transfer work if the first one failed?
Yes, a later transfer can result in pregnancy after an unsuccessful first attempt. Your physician can discuss your individual outlook based on the remaining embryos, medical history and cycle findings. No outcome can be guaranteed.
Will the doctor always change the medication protocol?
No. If the lining and hormone preparation were appropriate, the doctor may recommend a similar protocol. Changes should respond to medical findings, medication tolerance or another clear clinical reason.
Does a failed transfer mean the surrogate cannot carry a pregnancy?
No. One unsuccessful transfer does not establish that a surrogate cannot carry a pregnancy. The physician reviews the individual circumstances before recommending next steps.
Does acupuncture improve embryo transfer success?
Dr. Thomas discussed acupuncture as an option some patients find helpful for relaxation. She did not present it as a proven way to improve transfer success. Discuss any complementary treatment with the fertility clinic before adding it to a plan.
Watch the webinar and discuss your next steps
Whether you are preparing for your first transfer or considering another attempt, understanding the process can help you approach conversations with greater clarity.
Watch the full webinar with Dr. Semara Thomas for the complete discussion of transfer outcomes, cycle reviews, testing, costs and communication.
For guidance on the surrogacy process and the support available to your family, book a free consultation with ACRC Surrogacy.
This article summarizes an educational ACRC webinar and provides general information. It is not individualized medical or legal advice. Testing, treatment and transfer timing should be discussed with your treating fertility physician.
About the author:



Comments